* Buy Together & Subscriptions orders are not eligible for Cashback
Free shipping over $25
Free Shipping on All Orders Over $25.
You may request a return within 30 days from the date the product is shipped.
All returns may be tentative on brand approval.
The Best Eyeliner Picks
Make Up For Ever Kohl Pencil
This ultra-pigmented pick is infused with jojoba and macadamia oils, so it goes on smoothly and blends easily with a finger or a cotton swab. Results can be subtle or sultry. In 10 shades.
To buy: $17, sephora.com.
Buxom Smoky Eye Stick Twist up this waterproof crayon and either apply it close to lashes as a dramatic, smudgy liner or sweep it all over lids as a buildable cream shadow. Bonus: There’s a sharpener built into the cap. In eight shades.
To buy: $19, sephora.com.
Hard Candy Stroke of Gorgeous This budget-friendly pen is practically goofproof: The felt tip is firmer than a traditional brush, so you can draw a wiggle-free line every time. In three shades.
To buy: $5, walmart.com.
Sonia Kashuk Lay It on the Line Eye Liner Palette Apply one of the five powders dry for a soft daytime look, or dampen it with the enclosed brush for a bolder line. The compact’s mirror makes for easy application anywhere.
To buy: $13.29, target.com.
Yves Saint Laurent Eyeliner Effect Faux Cils The velvety formula goes on without skipping and stays put all day—even, as one tester reported, through a tearjerker. But it still comes off quickly with a facial cleanser. In six shades. (Liner brush not included.)
To buy: $28, yslbeautyus.com.
L'Oréal Paris Extra-Intense Liquid Pencil Eyeliner Don’t be fooled by how effortlessly this liner glides on: It won’t budge for up to 16 hours. Plus, the formula is nonirritating to contact-lens wearers. In four shades.